Comparing Diamond and Gemstone Stud Earrings


Some jewelry trends come and go, but stud earrings have stood the test of time. There’s no earring more elegant, understated, and beautiful than a stud earring. But, what kind should you choose? The choice often comes down to diamond or gemstone stud earrings; both kinds of stones have their advantages and disadvantages.

Use this handy guide to decide which kind of stone is right for you!

Gemstone Colors

alt_various_colored_gemstones_0.jpgGemstones come in bright blues, purples, pinks, greens, and reds, but most diamonds are colorless—and diamonds that do show a hint of color are considered low-quality (except for fancy colored diamonds, but those are a different story!)


If you want your earrings to really stand out, you may want to choose a gemstone with an eye-catching color. Deep red rubies or vibrant blue sapphires are chic and sophisticated, while bright blue aquamarines and pink sapphires are youthful and full of life. If you want to add color and personality to your jewelry collection, there’s no better way to do so than with gemstone stud earrings!

Gem Pricing & Costs

What budget do you have in mind for your new earrings? Both gemstones and diamonds are valuable, but if your budget is looking a little tight, gemstones are the better choice.

Gemstones typically do not cost as much as diamonds, so you will be able to get a bigger pair of gemstone earrings for the same price as a smaller pair of diamond studs. If size is important to you, keep this in mind when making your decision.

Gem Pricing & Costs

Gem Strength & Durability

The Mohs scale is a rating system used to determine the hardness of different stones by measuring each stone’s resistance to scratches. Diamonds have a rating of 10, which means they are very resistant. Although gemstones are durable, they do not score nearly as high as diamonds. Amethyst and citrine stones score a 7 on this scale, while rubies and sapphires both have a 9 rating.

If you are concerned about scratching your new earrings, it may be wise to choose diamonds or gemstones that rank on the higher end of the Mohs scale.

Gem Strength & Durability
Gemstone Rarity

Gemstone Rarity

When it comes to jewelry, something that is rare is considered to be more valuable. Many people believe that diamonds are the rarest gemstone, but according to the International Gem Society, that’s not the case. The IGS reports that current research has found that diamonds are one of the most common gems found in nature—and in jewelry. Think about how many people you know that own diamond jewelry. Do any of these people own gemstone stud earrings? Probably not. That means you can be a trendsetter and inspire others to wear beautiful gemstones by buying amethyst, ruby, sapphire, citrine, or aquamarine earrings.

Now that you know the advantages of both diamond and gemstone stud earrings, it’s time to make your decision. Above all else, be sure that you choose to buy your earrings from a reputable retailer so that you know you will be 100% satisfied with your purchase!

  1. Home
  2. Comparing Diamond Gemstone Stud Earrings
  3. Articles
  4. Comparing Diamond and Gemstone Stud Earrings